Home
About
Newsletter
Advice & Assistance
Researh & Briefings
Deaths, Inquests & Prosecutions
Corporate  Crime & safety Database
Safety Statistics
Obtaining Safety Information
CCA Responses to Consultation Documents
CCA Advocacy
CCA Press Releases
CCA Publications
Support the CCA
Bibliography
Search the CCA site
Contact Us
Quick Links ->
Parliamentary Ombudsman and the HSE
Back to HSE Main page

This page provides you information about investigations undertaken by the Parliamentary Ombudsman into the work of the Health and Safety Executive.

You cannot access this information on any
other website other than this one!

If you want to find out what is the Parliamentary Ombudsman or if you want to make a complaint against the Health and Safety Executive, please Click Here

The CCA has identified twelve complaints since 1990 concerning the HSE that have resulted in a set of findings published by the ombudsman.

Five of these reports concerned allegations of an inadequate investigation. Four of these were "partially upheld".
Five concerned allegations of inappropriate refusal to provide information. Only one of these was partially upheld, and four were not upheld
One concerned alleged inappropriate advice which was upheld
One concerned alleged mishandling of a complaint, which was partially upheld

The findings are either published in a summary form or in a full report.

Below you can access the summary reports of all the cases.

However, you can only access the full reports if they have been formally ‘laid before parliament’ - and not all of them have been. This depends on whether the Ombudsman considers it appropriate to do so.

When the report has been ‘laid before parliament’ (and subsequently published), you can access them here. Otherwise they are not available.

The only way of accessing the full reports concerning the ‘unpublished’ cases is through contacting the complainant or the MP involved in making the complaint on the complainants behalf.

The table below explains what is available. Click on the case number to see the summary, click on ‘download’ to download the full report. All the reports that can be downloaded are in "word"

Date
Case No
Title/Subject of Inquiry Title/Subject of Inquiry Full Report
2001 C.752/01 Conduct of an investigation into an industrial accident Partially Upheld Download
2000 C.515/00 Shortcomings in the investigation of a complaint about working conditions Partially Upheld Not Available
1999 A.7/99 Refusal to release information about workplace stress which was obtained by inspectors Partially Upheld Download
1998 C.66/98 Investigation into injury Partially Upheld Not Available
1996 C.958/96 Complaint concerning an investigation into an ‘accident’ at a school Partially Upheld Not Available
1996 A.34/96 Refusal to release a report of an accident investigation Not Upheld Download
1996 A.37/96 Refusal to disclose information about defects at a nuclear power station Not Upheld Download
1995 C.676/95 Provision of wrong advice by the HSE Upheld Not Available
1995 A.25/95 Refusal to release an assessment report relating to the feed pond at the Thermal Oxide Reprocessing Plant (THORP) at Sellafield Not Upheld Download
1995 A.32/95 Refusal to disclose information about prosecutions and enforcement notices free of charge Not Upheld Download
1993 C.724/93 Failure to investigate a reported incident Not Upheld Not Available
1991 C.132/91 Mishandling of a complaint about the use of wood treatment chemicals on domestic premises Partially Upheld Not Available

 

 

Page last updated on July 25, 2004